Immaculate Conception
 

Status: Active, Catholic

Also Known As: Immaculate

Founded: 1902
Construction: 1927

Price & Ardleigh
Philadelphia, PA 19138

http://www.archdiocese-phl.org/parishes/7170.htm

http://immaculateconception-phila.net/

 
Where It It?


Price & Ardleigh Streets, in the East Germantown section of Philadelphia

The Skinny


The Project returns to Germantown to check out the “other” Immaculate Conception (see Jenkintown), and boy, what a return it is. If you looked up “enormous” in the dictionary, you might just see a picture of this church. It’s almost larger than life itself. It towers over everything else in Germantown, and when you stand next to it you can’t help but feel dwarfed by its awesome expanse.

Inside, well…the best word is cavernous. As you’d expect from the outside, the interior is a cavernous mass of stone, culminating in a broad, expansive arched roof. Just looking at each individual brick in said roof, and imagining the labor it took to lay said bricks, well…it’s enough to inspire both awe and a splitting headache. Even more impressive is that it does it without columns. That's right, you get the full, expansive effect! Like our friend St. Martin of Tours, the interior also features a lot of tile work, but unlike St. Martin, it eschews the green for mostly red and gold, so it doesn’t seem like a gigantic shower.

Two interesting things stand out here. First, Immaculate has the same cruciform shape we've come to know and love. But the transcept isn't entirely rectangular, like we're used to seeing. Instead, each arm is home to a huge circular shrine featuring paintings of various saints. That’s unique enough, but it’s really strange to see how large the transcept really is. In most cruciform churches, the nave takes up most of a church’s length, with the transcept occupying on a small part. Here, though, the transpet is longer than nave, which makes for an unique effect.

Fat Girl Principle, v4: Fourteen people showed up for Saturday mass, most of them Black, so we certainly stuck out like sore thumbs. The pastor, Father John Holliday, invited us to do the dreaded “stand up and tell us where you’re from!” You’d think I’d be used to this by now, but somehow I always seem surprised when it happens.

Anyhow, this church is simply magnificent. It’s not quite as ornate as others we’ve seen, but it makes a gimmick out of being ridiculously gigantic. It’s not “European cathedral" gigantic, but it’s larger than anything in this area.

Size Rating: 10 out of 10

Ornamentation Rating: 8.5 out of 10

Overall Design Rating: 9.5 out of 10 crosses

How's It Doing?


In many ways this is the saddest church, but not for the reasons you might think. There’s some minor damage; some cracks here, some peeling paint there, but overall it’s in pretty good shape, and certainly very capable of life. And there is some; the people hold hands and great each other warmly, often shaking with two hands. The problem is that it might not be enough. I mentioned that 14 people attended the vigil mass. According to Father Holliday, the upper church can hold 1,400. That’s a lot of empty seats, and a lot of church going to waste.

Our Lady of Hope was physically a mess, so its attendance problems seemed only natural. Incarnation of Our Lord boasted a sparse English vigil mass, but it was held in the lower church, so the emptiness didn’t really bother you. (Plus you had the knowledge that the Spanish mass boasted a knockout crowd.) Here, though, you have a church that’s physically fine, yet nearly entirely deserted. Father Holliday didn’t get into financial specifics, or whether Sunday attendance was any better (not it could get worse), but he did admit that the numbers are not what they once were. I'll say--their average weekly attendance is only 195.

I don’t know what that means for the future of this parish, but you're not doing particularly well if you're averaging far fewer people than beleagured Our Lady of Hope. I still think this parish has a better shot, but I'm concerned nonetheless.

Emergency Rating: It might be too early for paddles, but at least make an appointment with the cardiologist.


Travel Tidbits


It’s in Germantown, so that knocks it down a few pegs. The church predictably has its own city block, so there’s a lot of parking street parking around it. We found one right in front of the church; given the attendance, you might, too.

Not a great area, but probably not one you have to worry about if you stay in sight of the church. I wouldn’t dally after the sun goes down, though.

Safety Rating: 7 out of 10 tire irons.

Interesting Note


As an addendum to the fat girl principle note above, one of the ushers handed us small gift bags as we left, filled with various pamphlets, the church bulletin, and a set of rosaries. The bags are even branded with the Immaculate Conception name. Nothing says, “Please come back!” like a bag full of gifts.

The Final Word


One of Philadelphia’s great churches, Immaculate Conception is a must-see, especially if its situation is as precarious as it seems.

 


© 2007 Philadelphia Church Project